Jack the Ripper's victims were NOT prostitutes, says historian

Jack the Ripper's victims were NOT prostitutes, says historian who claims sexist Victorian policemen unfairly labelled the working class women

  • The Ripper murdered five women but his identity has never been discovered 
  • Dr Hallie Rubenhold says the women had working-class jobs as maids or servants
  • She said researchers had never questioned the Victorian narrative about them

By Tim Stickings For Mailonline

Published: 08:24 EDT, 16 September 2018 | Updated: 20:32 EDT, 16 September 2018

Jack the Ripper's murder victims may not have been prostitutes, a historian has claimed. 

Dr Hallie Rubenhold has argued that 'sexist' attitudes of policemen at the time and researchers in the 130 years since have led to inaccurate beliefs about the women who were killed.

The historian, who is writing a history of the five known victims - Mary Ann Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes and Mary Jane Kelly - said the women had working-class jobs as servants and laundry maids.

The Ripper killed his victims in Whitechapel, east London, between September and November 1888, but his identity has never been discovered. 

The victims of Jack the Ripper, pictured in a contemporary illustration, may not have been prostitutes, according to a historian who blamed the sexism of policemen and researchers
The victims of Jack the Ripper, pictured in a contemporary illustration, may not have been prostitutes, according to a historian who blamed the sexism of policemen and researchers

The victims of Jack the Ripper, pictured in a contemporary illustration, may not have been prostitutes, according to a historian who blamed the sexism of policemen and researchers

Dr Rubenhold, whose book will be called The Five, said researchers had 'fixated' on the Ripper but never thought about who the women were, the Sunday Telegraph reported.  

She said: 'We glorify the Ripper, we have a whole industry based around him, a fascination with him, an unsolved murder mystery going on for 130 years. 

'We have never questioned 19th-century orthodoxy - the world in which they were killed was a world in which women were disrespected and treated as second-class citizens.'

One of the women had run a coffee shop in Poplar with their husband while another lived in the residence of a friend of the Prince of Wales, she said. 

Misogyny and sexism 'run very deep' in accounts of the Ripper and the women involved had been 'dehumanised' for 130 years, she said. 

On Twitter she said Mary Jane Kelly had been a sex worker and it was 'uncertain' if Elizabeth Stride had been soliciting on the night she was killed but the other three were not prostitutes.  

Mary Ann Nichols
Mary Ann Nichols
Annie Chapman
Annie Chapman

Mary Ann Nichols (left), thought to be Jack the Ripper's first victim, along with Annie Chapman

Mary Jane Kelly
Mary Jane Kelly
Elizabeth Stride
Elizabeth Stride

Mary Jane Kelly and Elizabeth Stride were also killed by Jack the Ripper in his 1888 spree 

Last month the claim sparked a row with fellow historian Paul Begg, who wrote a Definitive History of Jack the Ripper. 

He said: 'I don't mind you saying they weren't all prostitutes when your book is published and your evidence can be assessed, but doing so before then is you voicing your opinion as if it was fact.'

Dr Rubenhold replied: 'I'm free to publicise my books and my findings prior to publication. I am behaving professionally. 

'Prediction: no matter what appears in my book Paul Begg will find cause to rip it to shreds and denounce it.' 

The first of the 'canonical' five victims, Mary Nichols was found dead on the afternoon August 31, 1888, in a gateway in Buck's Row, Whitechapel. She had been disemboweled.

The mutilated corpse of Annie Chapman was found in the backyard of number 29 Hanbury Street at 6am, just over a week later on September 8, after the killer had made off with her womb.

An illustration shows the discovery of the mutilated body of Catherine Eddowes in 1888
An illustration shows the discovery of the mutilated body of Catherine Eddowes in 1888

An illustration shows the discovery of the mutilated body of Catherine Eddowes in 1888

Elizabeth Stride was found dead on September 30, in Dutfield's Yard, off Berner Street.

It is believed the Ripper may have been interrupted while cutting her throat, as the rest of her body was untouched.

Later the same day the body of Catherine Eddowes was found in Mitre Square in the City of London, with her uterus and kidney removed and her cheeks torn.

Mary Kelly, who was Jack the Ripper's final known victim, was found in her room in Miller's Court, off Dorset Street, on November 9.   

Victorian police suspected the Ripper was a butcher but they were never able to track him down. 

Last year a book claimed that an apparent 'confession' found beneath the floorboards of a Liverpool cotton merchant's bedroom was authentic.

The memoir includes the line: 'I give my name that all know of me, so history do tell, what love can do to a gentleman born. Yours Truly, Jack The Ripper.'

But critics questioned how the book, purportedly belonging to businessman James Maybrick, came to be found and whether the claims were genuine. 

Police discovering the body of one of Jack the Ripper's victims, probably Catherine Eddowes
Police discovering the body of one of Jack the Ripper's victims, probably Catherine Eddowes

Police discovering the body of one of Jack the Ripper's victims, probably Catherine Eddowes

A page from the Illustrated Police News page covering the the murders of Jack the Ripper
A page from the Illustrated Police News page covering the the murders of Jack the Ripper

A page from the Illustrated Police News page covering the the murders of Jack the Ripper

WHO WAS JACK THE RIPPER?

Jack the Ripper is thought to have killed at least five young women in Whitechapel, East London, between September and November 1888, but was never caught.

Numerous individuals have been accused of being the serial killer.

At the time, police suspected the Ripper must have been a butcher, due to the way his victims were killed and the fact they were discovered near to the dockyards, where meat was brought into the city.

There are several alleged links between the killer and royals. First is Sir William Gull, the royal physician. Many have accused him of helping get rid of the alleged prostitutes' bodies, while others claim he was the Ripper himself.

A book has named Queen Victoria's surgeon Sir John Williams as the infamous killer. He had a surgery in Whitechapel at the time.

Another theory links the murders with Queen Victoria's grandson, Prince Albert Victor, the Duke of Clarence.

At one point, cotton merchant James Maybrick was the number one suspect, following the publication of some of his diary which appeared to suggest he was the killer.

Some believe the diary to be a forgery, although no one has been able to suggest who forged it.

Other suspects include Montague John Druitt, a Dorset-born barrister. He killed himself in the Thames seven weeks after the last murder.

George Chapman, otherwise known as Severyn Kłosowski, is also a suspect after he poisoned three of his wives and was hanged in 1903.

Another suspected by police was Aaron Kosminski. He was admitted to Colney Hatch Lunatic Asylum and died there.

Dr Thomas Neill Cream poisoned four London prostitutes with strychnine and was hanged in 1892.

Some of the more bizarre links include Lewis Carroll, author of the Alice in Wonderland books, who taught at Christ Church until 1881 - which was at the forefront of the Ripper murder scenery.

Winston Churchill's father - Lord Randolph Churchill - has also been named as a potential suspect.

Crime writer Patricia Cornwell believes she has 'cracked' the case by unearthing evidence that confirms Walter Sickert, an influential artist, as the prime suspect. Her theories have not been generally accepted.

Author William J Perring raised the possibility that Jack the Ripper might actually be 'Julia' - a Salvation Army soldier.

In The Seduction Of Mary Kelly, his novel about the life and times of the final victim, he suggests Jack the Ripper was in fact a woman.

Advertisement
Read more:

Tagged as:

No tags for this article

RELATED CATEGORYMore

615 Views Comments

UN Security Council to hold emergency meeting over N Korea

The meeting aims to discuss a course of action in response to North Korea's actions The United Nations Security Council is to hold an emergency meeting

2356 Views Comments

President Trump to Sign Executive Order Declaring Pre-marital S*x, Abortion, Same S*x Marriage as Illegal

U.S President Donald Trump, is reportedly planning to sign an executive order declaring pre-marital s*x, same-s*x marriage and abortion to be wrong and make government

4968 Views Comments

BREAKING NEWS: French High-Speed Train Leaves 5 Dead After It Derails And Catches Fire Near Strasbourg

Five people have been killed as a train derailed and caught fire in Eckwersheim near Strasbourg in France. Rescue teams are working at the site. A